# Specification Quality Checklist: OperationRun Terminal Outcome Feedback v1

**Purpose**: Validate specification completeness, boundedness, and repo fit before implementation  
**Created**: 2026-05-05  
**Feature**: [spec.md](../spec.md)

## Content Quality

- [x] The package stays on one bounded terminal-outcome refinement over the existing shell activity hint instead of widening into a new activity center, dashboard card, or notification rewrite.
- [x] The spec remains product- and behavior-oriented and does not read like a low-level implementation diff.
- [x] The package explicitly names the repo-real anchors it builds on: `BulkOperationProgress`, the current shell activity view, `OperationUxPresenter`, `OperationRunProgressContract`, `ActiveRuns`, and the existing browser-session event flow.
- [x] Mandatory repo sections for scope, RBAC, Ops-UX, testing, proportionality, and candidate rationale are completed.

## Requirement Completeness

- [x] No `[NEEDS CLARIFICATION]` markers remain.
- [x] Requirements are testable and stay bounded to current shell terminal-success and terminal-follow-up semantics only.
- [x] The package explicitly preserves canonical `View operation` and `Show all operations` link generation instead of reopening routing decisions.
- [x] The package makes the lifecycle-sensitive tertiary contract explicit: `Hide activity` while active, `Dismiss` or `Close` for terminal success, and `Acknowledge` for unresolved terminal follow-up.
- [x] The package keeps acknowledgement browser-session-only and forbids DB-backed review state.
- [x] Planned validation commands match across `spec.md`, `plan.md`, and `tasks.md`.

## Candidate Selection Gate

- [x] The selected candidate exists in `docs/product/spec-candidates.md` and aligns with the roadmap's manual-promotion backlog.
- [x] The active queue remains intentionally empty, so this package records itself as a deliberate manual promotion rather than an automatic next-best-prep target.
- [x] No existing `269-*` spec package exists, and the current repo truth still leaves an open semantic gap even though Spec 268 and current code already introduced the broader shell activity surface.
- [x] The chosen slice is smaller and more repo-ready than deferred alternatives because it tightens one live shell contract before dashboard or broader progress follow-ups.

## Feature Readiness

- [x] The package reuses existing `OperationRun` truth and current shell helpers instead of introducing a second lifecycle or persisted projection.
- [x] The package explicitly leaves dashboard, tray, notification-policy, and progress-rollout work out of scope.
- [x] The package preserves current tenant-bound visibility and current Operations drill-through ownership.
- [x] The standards document update is included in the same slice so the terminal outcome rule becomes durable repo guidance.

## Test Governance

- [x] Planned proof stays bounded to focused Feature coverage plus one named browser smoke for the shell interaction contract.
- [x] No new heavy-governance, discovery, or browser family is introduced by default.
- [x] Fixture growth stays bounded to current `OperationRun` factories, tenant helpers, and existing shell smoke helpers.
- [x] The review outcome, workflow outcome, and test-governance outcome are carried into `plan.md` and `tasks.md`.

## Notes

- Reviewed against `docs/product/spec-candidates.md`, `docs/product/roadmap.md`, `.specify/memory/constitution.md`, `apps/platform/app/Livewire/BulkOperationProgress.php`, `apps/platform/resources/views/livewire/bulk-operation-progress.blade.php`, `apps/platform/tests/Feature/OpsUx/ActivityFeedbackSurfaceTest.php`, `apps/platform/tests/Feature/OpsUx/BulkOperationProgressDbOnlyTest.php`, and `apps/platform/tests/Browser/OpsUx/OperationActivityFeedbackSmokeTest.php` on 2026-05-05.
- Related-spec guardrail: Spec 268 remains the current shell-activity foundation and must not be rewritten back into prep-only state. This package only narrows the still-open terminal-outcome semantics seam.
- No application implementation was performed while preparing this package.

## Review Outcome

- **Outcome class**: `acceptable-special-case`
- **Workflow outcome**: `keep`
- **Test-governance outcome**: `keep`
- **Reason**: The automatic queue is intentionally empty, but this manual promotion is still justified because current repo truth shows an open terminal-outcome semantics gap on a live shell surface that is smaller and safer than the deferred dashboard or broader progress follow-ups.
- **Workflow result**: Ready for implementation.