# Specification Quality Checklist: Cross-Tenant Promotion Execution v1

**Purpose**: Validate specification completeness and repo fit before implementation  
**Created**: 2026-05-02  
**Feature**: [spec.md](../spec.md)

## Content Quality

- [x] The spec stays on one bounded follow-up over the already-implemented read-only compare and preflight slice instead of reopening portfolio compare foundations.
- [x] The spec is product- and behavior-oriented and does not read like an implementation diff.
- [x] The spec explicitly names the current repo-real foundations it builds on: `CrossTenantComparePage`, compare preview, promotion preflight, launch context, shared `OperationRun` UX, and current provider-write seams.
- [x] Mandatory repo sections for scope, RBAC, disclosure, testing, operation UX, and proportionality are completed.

## Requirement Completeness

- [x] No `[NEEDS CLARIFICATION]` markers remain.
- [x] Requirements are testable and bounded to one compare-page execution path.
- [x] The spec explains what remains in scope versus what is intentionally deferred.
- [x] Acceptance scenarios cover queueing execution, Monitoring continuity, and target-safe authorization behavior.
- [x] Edge cases cover stale preflight, no-ready execution, active-run dedupe, inaccessible tenants, and operational-control blocking.

## Candidate Selection Gate

- [x] The selected candidate exists in `docs/product/spec-candidates.md` and `docs/product/roadmap.md`.
- [x] `docs/product/implementation-ledger.md` still records promotion execution as the missing delta after compare and preflight.
- [x] Existing Spec 043 was checked for completion and treated as inherited context only; this package is explicitly the execution follow-up, not a rewrite of the read-only slice.
- [x] The chosen slice is smaller and higher-priority than deferred alternatives such as batch promotion, approvals, rollback, or mapping automation.

## Feature Readiness

- [x] The slice is an explicit delta follow-up over Spec 043 and current code, centered on one canonical compare page and one queued run path.
- [x] The spec explicitly forbids new panel or Laravel or Filament service-provider registration changes, new global-search scope, new asset strategy, and new promotion-draft persistence.
- [x] The spec explicitly records one canonical `promotion.execute` `OperationRun` path and shared Monitoring continuity.
- [x] The artifacts explicitly distinguish conditional `ProviderOperationRegistry` wiring from Laravel or Filament service-provider registration.
- [x] The spec acknowledges the current repo constraint that foreign-tenant `PolicyVersion` execution is not directly allowed and therefore requires a bounded bridge instead of a fake direct reuse claim.

## Test Governance

- [x] Planned validation stays bounded to `PortfolioCompare` unit and feature families plus one new bounded browser smoke file.
- [x] One new browser smoke file is explicitly justified because the feature adds a confirmation modal and compare-to-Monitoring handoff on a live Filament page.
- [x] The runtime proof commands stay consistent across spec, plan, and tasks, while Pint remains standard implementation hygiene.

## Notes

- Reviewed against `docs/product/spec-candidates.md`, `docs/product/roadmap.md`, `docs/product/implementation-ledger.md`, `specs/043-cross-tenant-compare-and-promotion/spec.md`, current PortfolioCompare code and tests under `apps/platform`, current `OperationRun` UX seams, current restore or policy-version write seams, and `.specify/memory/constitution.md` on 2026-05-02.
- No application implementation was performed while preparing this package.

## Review Outcome

- **Outcome class**: `acceptable-special-case`
- **Outcome**: `keep`
- **Reason**: The spec promotes the next real manual backlog item after the implemented read-only compare slice, stays on one canonical compare page plus one run type, explicitly rejects draft persistence and batch drift, and only introduces one justified browser smoke addition.
- **Workflow result**: Ready for implementation.