# Specification Quality Checklist: Spec 388 - Resolution Proof & Currentness Contract v1

**Purpose**: Validate specification completeness and preparation readiness before implementation
**Created**: 2026-06-19
**Feature**: `specs/388-resolution-proof-currentness-contract-v1/spec.md`

## Candidate Selection and Guardrails

- [x] CHK001 The candidate source is the direct user-provided Spec 388 draft attachment.
- [x] CHK002 The active auto-prep queue in `docs/product/spec-candidates.md` is acknowledged as empty/no-safe-automatic-target, and this spec is treated as manual user-provided promotion.
- [x] CHK003 No existing `specs/388-*` package or `*388*` branch existed before Spec Kit scaffold.
- [x] CHK004 Completed or implemented related specs 385, 386, and 387 are treated as dependency context only and are not rewritten.
- [x] CHK005 Close alternatives are deferred instead of hidden inside the primary scope.
- [x] CHK006 Candidate Selection Gate passes with scope narrowed to Review Publication Resolution proof/currentness V1.

## Scope and Constitution Fit

- [x] CHK007 The spec includes the mandatory Spec Candidate Check with approval class, score, red flags, and decision.
- [x] CHK008 The spec includes proportionality review for new DTO/value objects and proof state families.
- [x] CHK009 The plan keeps source truth in existing OperationRun, StoredReport, EvidenceSnapshot, EnvironmentReview, ReviewPack, and ReviewPublicationResolution records.
- [x] CHK010 No new proof persistence, migration, global registry, workflow engine, broad adapter package, Resource, route family, panel provider, or global search surface is approved by default.
- [x] CHK011 Restore, Provider Onboarding, Governance Inbox, Report Delivery, Cross-Tenant Promotion, and AI proof adapters are explicit follow-up candidates only.
- [x] CHK012 Existing workspace/managed-environment isolation and deny-as-not-found expectations are carried into proof evaluation.

## Requirements Quality

- [x] CHK013 Problem statement, business value, users, user stories, functional requirements, non-functional requirements, edge cases, out-of-scope boundaries, success criteria, assumptions, and open questions are present.
- [x] CHK014 Requirements define behavior for current, stale, superseded, missing, running, failed, inaccessible, unknown, usable, not usable, and inspection-only proof.
- [x] CHK015 Requirements state that successful OperationRun alone cannot complete artifact-backed steps without current artifact proof.
- [x] CHK016 Requirements state that newer current artifact proof supersedes older failed/running proof where appropriate.
- [x] CHK017 Requirements state that safe summaries exclude raw provider payloads, Graph responses, tokens, secrets, full report/evidence content, and raw exception messages.
- [x] CHK018 No `[NEEDS CLARIFICATION]` markers remain.

## UI, Filament, and Disclosure

- [x] CHK019 UI Surface Impact is explicit and limited to existing proof/state presentation plus customer no-leakage regression.
- [x] CHK020 UI/Productization Coverage reuses UI-101, UI-040, and UI-006 context without inventing a new route taxonomy.
- [x] CHK021 Technical proof remains collapsed/secondary by default.
- [x] CHK022 Customer-facing surfaces are explicitly forbidden from showing internal proof mechanics.
- [x] CHK023 Filament v5 / Livewire v4 compliance is stated.
- [x] CHK024 Laravel 12 panel provider location is stated as `apps/platform/bootstrap/providers.php`, with no provider change planned.
- [x] CHK025 No globally searchable Resource is added.
- [x] CHK026 No new destructive action is approved; existing high-impact actions remain confirmation-, authorization-, audit-, and test-gated.
- [x] CHK027 Asset strategy is stated as no new registered Filament assets expected.

## Plan and Task Readiness

- [x] CHK028 `spec.md`, `plan.md`, `tasks.md`, and this checklist exist.
- [x] CHK029 The plan identifies likely affected repo surfaces and avoids contradicting existing architecture.
- [x] CHK030 Tasks are ordered, small, verifiable, and include tests before implementation.
- [x] CHK031 Tasks include unit, feature, RBAC/scope, customer no-leakage, and optional browser/screenshot coverage.
- [x] CHK032 Validation commands use Sail-first paths and include focused Spec 388, Spec 386/387 regression, optional browser, Pint, and `git diff --check`.
- [x] CHK033 No full-suite success is implied by the preparation artifacts.

## Spec Readiness Gate

- [x] CHK034 Preparation artifacts are consistent on scope: Review Publication Resolution proof/currentness only.
- [x] CHK035 No task expands beyond `spec.md` or `plan.md`.
- [x] CHK036 Open questions are non-blocking.
- [x] CHK037 Spec Readiness Gate passes for a later implementation loop.

## Notes

- This checklist validates preparation artifacts only. It does not claim implementation, tests, browser smoke, or runtime behavior has been completed.