ahmido
54eb8ca065
Added a decision-first section to the Baseline Profile detail page. Includes request caching for summary metrics and corresponding browser/feature tests. Co-authored-by: Ahmed Darrazi <ahmed.darrazi@live.de> Reviewed-on: #440
2.4 KiB
2.4 KiB
Specification Quality Checklist: Spec 369 - Baseline Profile Decision View
Purpose: Validate specification completeness and readiness before implementation
Created: 2026-06-09
Feature: specs/369-baseline-profile-decision-view/spec.md
Candidate Selection Gate
- CHK001 Selected candidate exists in repo source material (
specs/368-platform-ui-signal-to-noise-browser-audit). - CHK002 Selected candidate is not already covered by an active or completed spec.
- CHK003 Completed specs are treated as historical context only.
- CHK004 Scope is the smallest viable slice: existing Baseline Profile detail page only.
- CHK005 Close alternatives are deferred instead of hidden in scope.
- CHK006 Candidate aligns with platform productization and governance operator value.
Content Quality
- CHK007 Spec has clear problem statement and user value.
- CHK008 Spec includes primary users/operators and user stories.
- CHK009 Functional and non-functional requirements are testable.
- CHK010 Out-of-scope boundaries are explicit.
- CHK011 Assumptions and risks are documented.
- CHK012 No
[NEEDS CLARIFICATION]markers remain.
Constitution Alignment
- CHK013 Workspace ownership and RBAC expectations are stated.
- CHK014 Existing high-impact actions retain confirmation, authorization, audit, and OperationRun behavior.
- CHK015 No new persisted truth, enum/status family, or broad abstraction is introduced.
- CHK016 Provider/platform boundary impact is bounded and documented.
- CHK017 UI/Productization Coverage is completed because a reachable UI surface changes.
- CHK018 Test-governance lane classification is present.
Spec Readiness Gate
- CHK019
spec.md,plan.md, andtasks.mdexist. - CHK020 Plan identifies likely affected repo surfaces and does not contradict current architecture.
- CHK021 Tasks are ordered, small, verifiable, and include tests/validation.
- CHK022 Open questions do not block safe implementation.
- CHK023 Scope is bounded enough for a later implementation loop.
- CHK024 Recommended next step is implementation, not additional preparation.
Review Outcome
- Candidate Selection Gate: PASS.
- Spec Readiness Gate: PASS after preparation analysis.
- Manual note: Implementation must stop and update the spec first if it needs new persistence, a new readiness taxonomy, a global UI framework, or baseline engine changes.