ahmido/TenantAtlas
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects 1 Releases Wiki Activity
196271ac01
TenantAtlas/specs/340-post-scope-contract-browser-verification-gate/findings.md
Ahmed Darrazi 196271ac01
Some checks failed
PR Fast Feedback / fast-feedback (pull_request) Failing after 59s
Details
test: add post-scope contract browser verification gate (340)
2026-05-31 16:22:35 +02:00

2.4 KiB
Raw Blame History

Spec 340 Findings

Severity Definitions

  • P1: Critical scope, authorization, credential-adjacent, or cross-environment ambiguity that blocks new feature work.
  • P2: Confirmed scope-contract drift that should be fixed before adjacent work compounds it, but without immediate credential/security risk.
  • P3: Bounded polish or clarity issue that does not block go/no-go.
  • backlog: Non-blocking productization or broader follow-up outside this verification gate.
  • blocked: Missing route, data, auth, or tooling prevented proof and must not be treated as pass.
  • not-applicable: Surface is not reachable or not relevant to the active contract in current repo truth.

P1 Findings

None confirmed.

P2 Findings

None confirmed.

P3 Findings

None confirmed.

Backlog Findings

B-340-001 Evidence Overview topbar wording should be reviewed in a future copy/productization pass

  • Surface: Evidence Overview helper copy.
  • Evidence: apps/platform/app/Filament/Pages/Monitoring/EvidenceOverview.php contains the helper text Use the Environment scope control in the top bar to choose an authorized environment.
  • Classification: backlog, not P1/P2.
  • Reason: Browser evidence confirms clean Workspace Hubs do not silently consume remembered environment state and filtered hubs use explicit environment_id; this wording does not itself apply a hidden filter. It can still be reviewed later because it may blur the distinction between topbar environment context and local hub filtering.
  • Smallest next action: handle in a future Evidence Overview copy/productization spec if product review wants stricter local-filter language.
  • Why not fixed here: Spec 340 is verification-only with No UI surface impact; changing runtime UI copy would exceed the no-runtime-change posture without P1/P2 browser drift.

Blocked Checks

None currently blocked. The implementation uses the existing Spec 322 browser harness to create deterministic workspace, environment, provider connection, evidence, alert, audit, review, decision, and operation records.

Notes

  • No screenshots containing credential-adjacent or sensitive payload data were captured.
  • Destructive or external-provider actions were not executed.
  • Search for topbar/local-filter copy found no instruction that the topbar acts as a local hub filter; B-340-001 is a non-blocking wording follow-up only.