ahmido/TenantAtlas
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects 1 Releases Wiki Activity
4a50c6a580
TenantAtlas/specs/395-product-surface-gate/checklists/requirements.md
ahmido 4a50c6a580 feat: add product surface gate and gatekeeper contracts (#466) 
Automated PR created by Codex via Gitea API.

Co-authored-by: Ahmed Darrazi <ahmed.darrazi@live.de>
Reviewed-on: #466
2026-06-21 19:44:56 +00:00

3.9 KiB
Raw Blame History

Requirements Checklist: Spec 395 - Product Surface Contract Enforcement and Surface Reduction Gate v1

Purpose: Validate preparation readiness for Spec 395 before implementation. Created: 2026-06-21 Feature: specs/395-product-surface-gate/spec.md

Spec Quality

  • CHK001 The selected candidate is directly provided by the user as Spec 395 and is not inferred from the automatic candidate queue.
  • CHK002 The completed-spec guardrail treats Specs 370, 375, and 377 as completed context only and does not reopen or rewrite their history.
  • CHK003 The spec states the concrete product problem: UI-affecting work can pass technically while expanding operator surface area, duplicating truth, exposing raw details, or skipping human/browser review.
  • CHK004 The spec defines the smallest enterprise-capable slice: a workflow/contract/guardrail gate with targeted tests, not a broad runtime redesign.
  • CHK005 Functional requirements are testable through documentation/template/guard assertions.
  • CHK006 Out-of-scope boundaries exclude broad page redesign, runtime Product Surface frameworks, migrations, models, routes, Filament page/resource changes, and browser visual regression infrastructure.
  • CHK007 Risks, assumptions, and follow-up candidates are recorded.

Constitution And Guardrails

  • CHK008 UI Surface Impact is completed as No UI surface impact for the default slice with a rationale.
  • CHK009 Product Surface Impact requires future UI-affecting specs to declare page archetype, surface budget, technical demotion, browser proof, human sanity, and exception handling.
  • CHK010 Cross-cutting shared pattern reuse names existing UI bloat/productization guards and avoids a runtime UI framework.
  • CHK011 OperationRun UX impact states no OperationRun behavior is touched and future OperationRun links should be demoted by default.
  • CHK012 Provider boundary treatment keeps provider-specific terms in Technical Annex/provider diagnostics, not platform-core product vocabulary.
  • CHK013 Proportionality review justifies a narrow workflow gate and rejects full redesign, visual regression, and runtime taxonomy/framework work.
  • CHK014 RBAC, workspace/tenant isolation, auditability, and data minimization are addressed as no-runtime-impact constraints.
  • CHK015 Test governance names surface-guard / heavy-governance ownership and forbids hidden browser/DB fixture cost.
  • CHK016 Filament v5 / Livewire v4 compliance, provider registration, global search, destructive action, asset, testing, and deployment posture are stated in the plan.

Task Readiness

  • CHK017 tasks.md includes repo-truth and completed-spec source verification before implementation edits.
  • CHK018 tasks.md includes canonical contract/documentation tasks before template references.
  • CHK019 tasks.md includes Spec Kit template, AGENTS, and PR checklist gate tasks.
  • CHK020 tasks.md includes targeted guard-test and lane-registration tasks.
  • CHK021 tasks.md includes a stop-before-runtime-UI-change boundary and follow-up-candidate path.
  • CHK022 tasks.md includes validation, browser/no-browser rationale, human sanity, and implementation-report tasks.
  • CHK023 tasks.md includes explicit non-goals to prevent runtime UI redesign creep.

Preparation Outcome

  • CHK024 Candidate Selection Gate result: pass for a user-provided explicit candidate.
  • CHK025 Spec Readiness Gate result: pass for preparation.
  • CHK026 Plan Readiness Gate result: pass for preparation.
  • CHK027 Tasks Readiness Gate result: pass for implementation handoff.
  • CHK028 Workflow outcome: keep as prepared, implementation not started.

Notes

This checklist validates preparation only. It does not claim Product Surface Contract implementation, guard-test execution, PR-template enforcement, browser verification, human sanity review, or runtime UI reduction.