TenantAtlas/specs/368-platform-ui-signal-to-noise-browser-audit/page-scorecard.csv

id,panel,path,page_title,surface_type,audience,scope_type,screenshot_path,primary_question_clear_score,decision_first_score,signal_to_noise_score,progressive_disclosure_score,metadata_separation_score,zero_state_suppression_score,next_action_score,evidence_access_score,customer_safety_score,overall_score,severity,top_problem,recommended_action,recommended_spec_candidate
001,admin,/admin/workspaces/3/environments/b0091e5d-944f-4a34-bcd9-12cbfb7b75cf,YPTW2 Action needed,operator_surface,operator,tenant_scoped,artifacts/screenshots/admin/001-operator-surface-dashboard-environment-dashboard.png,4,4,3,4,3,3,4,3,4,3.6,P2,"Dashboard answers readiness, but navigation chrome and repeated zero/health metrics compete with the decision.",Keep readiness decision first; suppress zero-pressure cards and demote support signals.,Spec B
002,admin,/admin/workspaces/33/operations,Operations,operator_surface,operator,workspace_scoped,artifacts/screenshots/admin/002-operator-surface-list-operations-hub.png,4,4,3,4,3,3,4,3,4,3.6,P2,Operations hub is decision-oriented but repeats counts/status and shows zero metrics beside no-attention copy.,Collapse zero-state counts and keep failed/blocked queue as the dominant operator path.,Spec B
003,admin,/admin/workspaces/33/operations/69,Operation #69,operator_surface,operator,workspace_scoped,artifacts/screenshots/admin/003-operator-surface-view-operation-run.png,5,5,4,4,3,4,4,4,4,4.1,P2,"Operation detail is strong, but lifecycle/timing/metadata still take visible space in the default view.","Move timing, context, and metadata further into technical detail/sidebar.",Spec B
004,admin,/admin/workspaces/33/environments/spec-352-audit-no-urgent/backup-sets,Backup Sets,workflow_surface,operator,tenant_scoped,artifacts/screenshots/admin/004-workflow-surface-list-backup-sets.png,4,4,4,4,4,4,4,3,4,3.9,P2,"Backup list is scan-friendly, but backup quality and operation links need a stronger usability decision.",Keep quality sentence; add a single dominant backup usability/filter decision.,Spec B
005,admin,/admin/workspaces/33/environments/spec-352-audit-no-urgent/backup-sets/25,View Backup Set,workflow_surface,operator,tenant_scoped,artifacts/screenshots/admin/005-workflow-surface-view-backup-set.png,4,4,3,3,2,4,3,3,4,3.4,P2,"Backup set view exposes lifecycle, timing, related context, and technical detail close to the main decision.",Make usability and included items primary; move IDs/timing/technical detail to sidebar/details.,Spec B
006,admin,/admin/workspaces/33/environments/spec-352-audit-no-urgent/restore-runs/4,View Restore Run,workflow_surface,operator,tenant_scoped,artifacts/screenshots/admin/006-workflow-surface-view-restore-run.png,5,5,4,4,4,3,4,4,4,4.1,P2,"Restore run view has the right primary question, but still shows proof gaps and technical preview evidence prominently.",Keep safety/proof decision first; collapse technical preview evidence by default.,Spec B
007,admin,/admin/workspaces/33/environments/spec-352-audit-no-urgent/restore-runs/create,Create Restore Run,workflow_surface,operator,tenant_scoped,artifacts/screenshots/admin/007-workflow-surface-create-restore-create-wizard.png,5,5,4,4,4,4,5,4,4,4.3,P2,Restore wizard is process-oriented and clear; default source-required state is still dense.,Preserve process flow; ensure preview/details stay collapsed until a backup is selected.,Spec B
008,admin,/admin/baseline-profiles/4,View Spec 352 Calm Baseline spec-352-audit-no-urgent 20260604115033,decision_surface,operator,mixed,artifacts/screenshots/admin/008-decision-surface-view-baseline-profile.png,3,3,2,2,2,4,4,2,3,2.8,P1,"Baseline profile view is dominated by long names, normalized scope terms, metadata, and technical governance vocabulary.",Create a baseline decision summary and move normalization lineage/metadata to details.,Spec B
009,admin,/admin/workspaces/33/environments/spec-352-audit-no-urgent/baseline-compare,Baseline Compare,decision_surface,operator,tenant_scoped,artifacts/screenshots/admin/009-decision-surface-report-baseline-compare.png,5,5,4,4,4,4,4,4,4,4.2,P2,"Baseline compare is one of the better decision surfaces, but notification/chrome repetition still distracts.",Use as a target pattern; reduce notification replay in first viewport.,Spec A
010,admin,/admin/workspaces/33/environments/spec-352-audit-review-output/evidence/22,Sign in,evidence_surface,auditor,tenant_scoped,artifacts/screenshots/blocked-or-error/010-evidence-surface-view-evidence-snapshot-error.png,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,P1,Evidence snapshot detail redirected to admin login with available smoke context.,Clarify route/auth requirements or provide documented fixture access for evidence surface audits.,Spec C
011,customer,/admin/reviews/workspace,Customer Review Workspace,customer_surface,customer,customer_scoped,artifacts/screenshots/customer/011-customer-surface-report-customer-review-workspace.png,5,5,3,4,4,4,5,4,4,4.2,P2,"Customer review workspace is customer-safe overall but dense, with many status phrases and actions in the first viewport.",Keep customer outcome copy; reduce competing action/link density.,Spec C
012,customer,/admin/workspaces/32/environments/spec-351-browser-ready-draft/environment-reviews/41,View Review,customer_surface,customer,tenant_scoped,artifacts/screenshots/customer/012-customer-surface-view-environment-review.png,4,4,3,3,3,4,4,4,4,3.7,P2,Review detail has customer-safe framing but high status repetition and broad navigation chrome.,Make acknowledgement/outcome the first card and collapse supporting diagnostics.,Spec C
013,customer,/admin/workspaces/32/environments/spec-351-browser-ready-draft/review-packs/25,View Review Pack,customer_surface,auditor,tenant_scoped,artifacts/screenshots/customer/013-customer-surface-view-review-pack.png,4,4,4,4,4,4,4,5,5,4.2,P2,Review pack detail is comparatively strong; keep evidence/output readiness language reusable.,Reuse as customer output pattern.,Spec C
014,customer,/admin/workspaces/32/environments/spec-351-browser-ready-draft/stored-reports/51,View Stored Report,customer_surface,auditor,tenant_scoped,artifacts/screenshots/customer/014-customer-surface-view-stored-report.png,4,4,4,4,4,4,4,5,5,4.2,P2,Stored report detail is customer/auditor-ready but still carries operator navigation shell.,Keep report readiness first; consider customer-mode shell reduction later.,Spec C
015,admin,/admin/workspaces/33/environments/spec-352-audit-provider-blocker/diagnostics,Environment Diagnostics,diagnostic_surface,support,tenant_scoped,artifacts/screenshots/admin/015-diagnostic-surface-diagnostics-environment-diagnostics.png,4,3,4,3,3,4,3,3,3,3.3,P2,"Diagnostics page is clearly diagnostic, but guidance to resolve provider blockers should be more dominant.",Add what failed / what to check next summary before technical sections.,Spec D
016,admin,/admin/workspaces/33/environments/spec-352-audit-provider-blocker/required-permissions,Sign in,configuration_surface,support,tenant_scoped,artifacts/screenshots/blocked-or-error/016-configuration-surface-settings-required-permissions-error.png,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,P1,Required permissions route redirected to admin login with available smoke context.,Document fixture/access preconditions; audit page once reachable.,Spec D
017,admin,/admin/provider-connections,Provider Connections,configuration_surface,operator,mixed,artifacts/screenshots/admin/017-configuration-surface-list-provider-connections.png,3,3,3,3,3,4,3,2,3,3,P2,Provider connections list shows provider lifecycle/capability fields as table truth without a strong readiness decision.,Introduce provider readiness summary and make technical columns secondary.,Spec D
031,system,/system,Sign in,system_surface,platform_admin,system_scoped,artifacts/screenshots/blocked-or-error/031-system-surface-dashboard-system-dashboard-error.png,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,P1,System dashboard redirected to system login; no system smoke auth path was available.,Add documented system-panel audit fixture or mark system panel as separately auditable.,Spec D
032,system,/system/ops/runs,Sign in,system_surface,platform_admin,system_scoped,artifacts/screenshots/blocked-or-error/032-system-surface-list-system-operations-error.png,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,P1,System operations redirected to system login; no system smoke auth path was available.,Add documented system-panel audit fixture or mark system panel as separately auditable.,Spec D